I like both!

Although I like Evanna's character more than Emma's, I think Emma is the better actress.

I love both!

I totally agree with princess829.

both

I like Luna more, but Emma is a much better actress. Both though.

I was really impressed with Evanna. I was scared in the beginning before OOTP came out on if she was going to be good or not and she blew me away. I do love Emma, but not as much as Evanna.

Emma is the best youngere Actress in this Series,she is the best after Helena in the whole serie.

You can see that Evanna's acting. To me it doesn't look natural when she acts.

I don't like Emma very much

I think if Evanna started at Emma's age, she wouldn't have been as good.

I dont 100% like Emma's portrayal of Hermione sometimes, just little things, i think she says it wrong or with the wrong emotion if that makes sense.

She did very well in DH though.

They're both great

Before DH I was NEVER complementary of Watson's acting. She was just so mediocre it was distracting. DH was the very first time she did better in my opinion, but she was still out acted by the other two leads. Evanna is the perfect Luna, but I cannot yet say anything about other projects which will be the real clincher.

^ I disagree. I thought she was loads better than Rupert & Dan in Deathly Hallows personally. By far superior.

I HATE Emma's acting in CoS through HBP, it makes me angry (watch her eyebrows in OoTP- THEY NEVER STOP MOVING). Evanna IS Luna, and I think she's easily the best child actor in the series.

"Evanna is Luna"
Quote taken from J.K.Rowling, but as much as I like Emma, I agree with Jo. Evanna RULES!

Eugh, I hate it when people talk about Emma's eyebrows. Honestly. Are you seriously that engrossed in somebody's eyebrows while watching a film?!

Her eyebrows aren't as bad as everyone makes them out to be. I can tell you now that Emma's eyebrows do not affect my enjoyment of the film or her acting.